31 August 2015

RI bushfire risk consultation

Raymond Island bushfire risk community consultation planning
MINUTES Meeting 2

Date:               Wednesday 26 August 2015
Time:               10:15am – 11:30am
Venue:                        Raymond Island Community Hall
Present:          Chair: Dave Munday (independent facilitator)
RICA / Community: Jack Pearce, David Prasad, Tom Ponting, Warwick Hall, Jack Holbrook                                                                                     
DELWP: Mick Beckers, Willow Bourke, Catherine Burton (minutes)
GLaWAC: Grattan Mullett
Apologies:      DELWP: Brad Fisher, Leona Waldegrave-Knight      
Parks Victoria: Jeremy Tscharke

Purpose of this meeting
The community consultation on managing bushfire risk on Raymond Island will begin in late September, guided by the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) and Parks Victoria, and is occurring due to concerns raised by residents earlier this year in response to the planned burning and slashing programs.
The process will be overseen by a community working group, which will include local community members and staff from DELWP, Parks Victoria and Gunaikurnai Land and Waters Aboriginal Corporation (GLaWAC).
The purpose of this meeting is to:
·         Clarify the purpose and parameters of the group
·         Assess the expressions of interest (EOIs) that have been received against a set of criteria
·         Develop the process for follow-up for both successful and unsuccessful applicants.

Purpose of the group overseeing the consultation process
The purpose of the group is to ensure that the consultation process put in place will effectively engage with the broader Raymond Island community. Desired outcomes are:
·         Raised awareness of local bushfire management issues
·         The community had the opportunity to have their views heard
·         The community had the opportunity to contribute into how future bushfire management will look on the island.
The group is not a forum for discussing the bushfire management issues involved; rather it is focused on developing the process and opportunities for the broader Raymond Island community to be engaged to the best possible degree in the conversation. 

Key tasks include:
·         Developing and informing communication processes to engage the community to explore bushfire management options
·         Prepare and disseminate information relating to the process with best possible reach into the community
·         Represent Raymond Island interests
·         Create a chance for all islanders to be heard and to contribute.

EOI assessment
The applicants were assessed against four criteria:
1.      Working with others – Experience working with teams
2.      Planning ability – Involvement in leadership roles
3.      Connection to Raymond Island community – Evidence of links into the local community, e.g. involvement in local groups
4.      Representation of local groups – CFA, Emergency Preparation, Gunaikurnai, Koala and Wildlife Shelter, Landcare, RICA, and the broader community.

·         A cap on the numbers of members of the group was set at 11.
·         Six applicants were successful.
·         Five places are set for agency staff.
·         Follow up to all applicants will be a letter and telephone call.
·         Feedback from the group on the fairness of the process used for determining the working group, on a scale of 1 – 5 where 1 = not fair, 2 = slightly fair, 3 = moderately fair, 4 = very fair, and 5 = extremely fair, was unanimous at 4, a very fair process was used.

General Discussion
·         Current fuel breaks will continue to be maintained however fuel reduction measures proposed for 2015 including planned burning and mulching have been placed on hold until after the consultation process is complete. 
·         In terms of managing cultural values, GLaWAC works with DELWP and Parks Victoria to assess the fire operations plan and sort any issues including the protection of registered sites listed on the database.
·         Next steps include setting the date with the members of the new group for the first meeting, which is expected to be late next week (Thursday 3 or Friday 4 September).

Actions
1.      Catherine to provide minutes for community dissemination – COMPLETED
2.      Catherine to provide follow-up to all applicants - COMPLETED

3.      Catherine to submit article for Raymond Island Landcare newsletter September issue – COMPLETED